Negotiating Patent Licensing Terms

Negotiating licensing terms can be a complex process, as it requires balancing the needs and interests of both the licensor and licensee. Whether you are licensing intellectual property (IP) such as patents, trademarks, software, or creative works (music, art, etc.), it is essential to approach negotiations strategically. 

​

Understand Your Objectives

 

Before entering into negotiations, clarify your own objectives :

 

• Licensor : Are you seeking to maximise revenue, expand brand reach, or retain control over your IP?

• Licensee : Are you looking to reduce upfront costs, secure exclusivity, or access particular markets or technologies ?

 

Establish your non-negotiables (what you must have) and your flexible points (what you can compromise on). Consider the long-term relationship, not just the short-term deal.

​

Know the Key Terms in Licensing Agreements

​

Familiarise yourself with the common terms and provisions in licensing agreements:

​

• Scope of the License : Clearly define the IP being licensed, its usage (exclusive or non-exclusive), and the territories where it can be used.

• Duration : Determine the length of the agreement, renewal options, and any termination rights.

• Royalties/Payment Structure : This includes the rate of royalty payments, whether they are lump sum or based on performance (e.g., sales percentage).

• Upfront Fees and Milestone Payments : Determine if any upfront payments are required, and how milestone payments will be structured based on performance or development milestones.

• Minimum Sales Requirements : Licensors may require licensees to meet specific sales thresholds to maintain the license.

• Quality Control and Use of the IP : This ensures that the licensee uses the IP in a way that reflects the licensor’s standards and brand.

• Exclusivity Clauses : Decide if the license will be exclusive (only one licensee) or non-exclusive (multiple licensees).

• Sub-licensing Rights : Determine if the licensee can sublicense the IP to others.

• Audit Rights : Both parties should have the ability to audit payments and performance to ensure terms are being met.

​

Research and Benchmarking

​

Market Research : Look at comparable licensing deals in your industry to understand what is typical regarding royalties, fees, and other terms.

​

• IP Valuation : Understand the value of your intellectual property or the IP you are licensing. This can involve assessing the strength of the patent, brand, technology, or content in the marketplace.

​

Research both the financial stability and reputation of the other party to assess their ability to uphold the agreement and meet their financial obligations.

​

Understand the Other Party’s Position

​

In any negotiation, understanding the other party’s goals is critical.

​

• For the Licensor : What are the other party’s capabilities, market reach, and track record? Are they likely to succeed in using the IP in a way that benefits both sides?

• For the Licensee : What is the value proposition of the IP to their business? Do they require exclusivity? Do they have the resources to meet sales or quality standards?

​

Establish a Negotiation Strategy

​

• Be Clear About Your Needs : Determine your key priorities (e.g., exclusivity, royalties, control, etc.) and be prepared to defend them.

• Negotiate on More than Just Money : In many cases, the non-financial terms (like territory, sub-licensing rights, etc.) can be more important than the monetary aspect.

• Use a Tiered Approach : If you're negotiating royalties, for example, consider different levels based on performance or sales (e.g., lower royalty rates for the first few years, with an increase as sales rise).

• Prepare for Concessions : Know where you can afford to be flexible and where you cannot. Be prepared to trade concessions for something that adds value to the deal.

• Consider the Relationship : Licensing agreements often involve long-term relationships, so maintaining a professional, cordial tone during negotiations is important.

​

Review and Draft the Contract

 

Once you've agreed on key terms, have a lawyer draft a formal licensing agreement that:

​

• Defines the IP clearly.

• Clarifies rights and obligations.

• Ensures dispute resolution mechanisms are in place.

​

Important clauses to include

​

Indemnification Clause : Protects the licensor from any legal claims arising from the licensee’s use of the IP.

Confidentiality Clause : Prevents either party from disclosing sensitive business information.

Termination Clause : Specifies the conditions under which the agreement can be terminated (e.g., breach of contract, failure to meet sales targets).

​

Anticipate Possible Challenges

​

Anticipate challenges and prepare to negotiate solutions in advance.

​

Underperformance : Licensees may fail to meet sales targets or other expectations. This can lead to renegotiations or termination of the agreement.

Infringement : If the licensee is using the IP in a way that infringes on other rights or laws, it can affect the entire agreement.

Breach of Terms : Clearly define the actions that constitute a breach and the remedies available.

​

Leverage Expert Advice

​

Seek guidance from IP professionals, lawyers, and financial experts when needed. An experienced IP attorney can help.

​

Draft the agreement

​

• Ensure it complies with the relevant laws.

• Help resolve any complex issues during negotiations.

​

Finalising the Deal

​

After you and the other party come to a consensus on the terms, the agreement will need to be signed. Depending on the complexity of the licensing deal, the signatures may require witnesses or notarization.

 

Ongoing Management

 

Once the agreement is in place, ensure regular follow-ups and audits are conducted to monitor compliance with the terms. Licensing agreements may evolve over time, so ensure there are provisions for renegotiating terms as needed.

 

By thoroughly preparing, understanding the key terms of licensing agreements, and approaching negotiations with flexibility, you can successfully navigate licensing deals that benefit both parties