Negotiating the Sale of a Patent

Negotiating patent sale terms is a crucial step when transferring intellectual property (IP). Whether you are the seller or the buyer, the terms of the sale should be clear, mutually beneficial, and legally binding.

​

Determine the Value of the Patent

Before entering negotiations, it's important to assess the patent's value. Factors include.

• Market potential : How valuable is the technology in the marketplace? Is there a strong demand for it?

• Patent strength : Is the patent robust (e.g., it has broad claims and minimal risk of being invalidated)?

• Licensing potential : Can the patent be licensed to others for additional revenue?

• Enforceability : How easily can the patent be defended in a legal dispute?

• Remaining patent life : The expiration date and any ongoing maintenance fees that need to be considered.

Having a good sense of the patent’s value helps set an appropriate asking price and ensures fair negotiations.

Understand the Types of Patent Sales

Patent sales can take different forms, which will influence the terms.

​

• Outright Sale (Assignment) : The seller transfers full ownership to the buyer. The buyer obtains all rights to the patent, including enforcement rights, the ability to license, and the freedom to sell.

• Exclusive License : The seller retains ownership but grants the buyer exclusive rights to use, license, or sell the patent in certain regions or fields of use.

• Non-Exclusive License : The seller retains ownership and can grant the patent to multiple buyers, often for a lower price.

• Partnership/Joint Venture : In some cases, a partnership or joint venture may be formed, where both parties contribute to the development and commercialisation of the patented technology.

Understanding which form of sale is best for both parties will shape your negotiation.

Key Terms to Negotiate

Some common terms and clauses to negotiate in a patent sale agreement include :

• Lump-Sum Payment : One-time payment for the full purchase price.

• Royalties : Ongoing payments based on a percentage of sales or profits derived from the patent.

• Milestone Payments : Payments made upon achieving certain commercialisation or development milestones.

• Assignment Clauses : The agreement should specify that the patent will be fully assigned to the buyer, transferring ownership.

• Formalities : Ensure the assignment is recorded with the relevant patent office to protect the buyer’s ownership rights.

• Patent Validity : Sellers typically warrant that the patent is valid and enforceable.

• No Encumbrances : The seller should confirm that the patent is free of any liens, legal challenges, or encumbrances that could affect its use or value.

• Non-Infringement : A warranty that the patent does not infringe on any other parties' IP rights.

• Indemnification : The seller may agree to indemnify the buyer against claims or legal actions related to the patent (e.g., if another party sues for infringement).

• Right to Use : Define whether the seller retains any rights to use the patent (such as in exclusive licensing agreements).

• Confidentiality : Terms related to the protection of sensitive information, especially during the negotiation phase and post-sale.

• Dispute Resolution : It’s essential to decide how disputes will be resolved (mediation, arbitration, or litigation) and the jurisdiction that will apply.

Scope of the Patent

Define the scope of the sale, particularly if the sale includes one or more patents.

​

• Multiple patents : The sale includes related patents or patent applications (e.g., continuations, divisional patents).

• Geographic scope : Ensure the geographic regions covered by the sale are well-defined, especially in international sales. Some patents may only apply in certain countries or regions.

• Field of Use : Specify the particular field or industry where the patent can be exploited. An exclusive license may limit its use to certain markets, applications, or technologies.

Post-Sale Obligations

If there are post-sale obligations (e.g., the seller must provide technical support, maintain related patents, or assist with enforcement), these should be clearly defined :

• Technical Assistance : The seller might need to offer post-sale support, such as providing expertise or documentation to help the buyer commercialise the patent.

• Ongoing Royalties or Performance Benchmarks : If royalties are part of the deal, the seller might need to monitor the buyer’s performance and report revenue.

​

Due Diligence

Both parties will likely conduct due diligence to verify patent ownership, status, and any encumbrances. This process involves :

​

• Patent Search and Review : Ensuring that the patent is valid and has not been previously sold or encumbered.

• Legal and Technical Review : Verifying the technical scope and patent claims to ensure they align with the buyer’s intended use.

• Third-Party Rights : Verifying that the patent does not infringe on the rights of third parties and that the seller has the right to sell or license the patent.

Negotiation Tactics

​

Effective negotiation strategies include :

​

• Clarify Objectives : Each party should clearly articulate its goals (e.g., upfront payment vs. long-term royalties, total control vs. licensing).

• Leverage Competition : If there are multiple buyers or patents, use this to strengthen your bargaining position.

• Be Transparent : For a smoother process, be open about the patent’s value and any risks (e.g., pending litigation, potential challenges).

• Know When to Walk Away : If the terms aren’t favourable, be prepared to exit negotiations or look for alternative buyers/sellers.

​

Legal Considerations

​

Patents are legal documents, and ensuring that the sale complies with relevant patent laws is critical.

​

• Jurisdictional Considerations : Different countries have different patent laws. A sale should comply with local laws and any international treaties (such as the Patent Cooperation Treaty).

• Legal Assistance : Engage patent attorneys to draft or review the sale agreement. They will help with any regulatory compliance issues and ensure the terms are enforceable.

Closing the Sale

Once the terms have been agreed upon :

​

• Draft the Agreement : A legally binding sale or license agreement should be drafted, outlining all the terms discussed.

• Execution and Recordation : Both parties will sign the agreement, and the patent assignment should be recorded with the relevant patent office to ensure the transfer is official.

• Final Payment : Once the agreement is signed, the agreed-upon payment (or first instalment, if applicable) should be made.

Summary

​

Negotiating patent sale terms involves a combination of understanding the value and potential of the patent, defining clear contractual terms, and protecting your interests through legal safeguards. By taking these steps, both parties can ensure a fair and successful transfer of the patent.