Licensing Negotiations and Negotiating

Negotiation is an art that lacks universal rules. Success depends on the context and the desired outcomes. For instance, negotiating licensing terms with a manufacturer requires a vastly different strategy compared to resolving an infringement case.

 

To excel as a negotiator, consider the following principles

 

Know your objectives : Always be clear about what you aim to achieve.

Understand all positions : Grasp both your stance and that of the other party.

Maintain integrity : Uphold personal and professional ethics.

Be willing to walk away : Avoid settling for unfavourable terms.

 

Flexibility is also essential : For example, insisting on terms a company cannot afford is futile. Most successful agreements involve compromise, enabling both parties to meet their goals in mutually acceptable ways.

 

Negotiating Intellectual Property (IP)

 

Negotiating IP is complex and demanding, requiring careful preparation and strategic foresight. Avoid common pitfalls by keeping the following considerations in mind.

 

Preparation. The Key to Success : Negotiations often begin well before sitting at the table. Preparation and planning lay the foundation for productive discussions.

Define Objectives and Scope : Before negotiations begin, both parties must clearly define the scope and objectives, such as whether the goal is the sale, transfer, or licensing of IP, and specify the rights involved.

Build a Strong Team : Negotiating IP terms is a complex task requiring specialised knowledge. A skilled team - comprising legal, financial, and technical experts—ensures that all aspects of the agreement are thoroughly addressed. For example, licensing agreements often include intricate financial and technical components that demand expert input.

Conduct Due Diligence : Gathering as much information as possible before negotiations is critical. Conduct thorough due diligence to understand the other party’s position. This preparation facilitates mutual understanding and sets the stage for productive discussions.

 

At the Negotiating Table

 

When negotiations move to face-to-face discussions, your demeanour and strategy play a crucial role in the outcome.

 

Project Strength : Your confidence and composure send a strong message. For instance, if the other party perceives you as desperate, their terms will reflect this. Conversely, if they see you as having viable alternatives, they may offer more favourable terms.

Avoid Weaknesses : While a strong character is essential, experience, knowledge, and skill are equally critical. A lack of these attributes often leads to suboptimal deals.

Achieving a Win-Win Outcome : IP negotiations often take time, requiring persistence and focus. Without the determination to see the process through, it’s easy to become disillusioned and settle for less than optimal terms.

 

A successful negotiation is one where both parties make concessions to satisfy the other’s interests. Taking  a “my way or the highway” approach very rarely leads to success. Instead, focus on the core issues and be willing to find common ground.

​

Practical Tips for IP Negotiations

​

• Clarify your goals : Know what you want and stay focused.

• Understand strengths and weaknesses : Assess both your position and the other party's.

• Leverage expertise : Surround yourself with a team that complements your skill gaps.

• Prepare thoroughly : Research the other party and outline multiple strategies.

• Craft a compelling presentation : Start by gaining agreement on small points to build momentum.

• Prioritise flexibility : Propose options rather than issuing ultimatums.

• Maintain integrity : Perception matters; act professionally at all times.

• Exercise patience : Negotiations can take time - stay the course.

• Embrace silence : Strategic pauses can be powerful.

• Know when to walk away : Accept only terms that align with your objectives.

​

Finally, whatever agreement you reach, embrace it and move forward with confidence. Remember, no matter how challenging negotiations may become, they are opportunities for growth, not threats to your survival.