The Risks in Selling a Patent

Selling a patent can generate immediate financial rewards, but it also introduces various risks and threats, especially since patents are valuable intellectual property assets. 

​

Loss of Future Revenue Potential

 

Missed Royalties and Licensing : Selling a patent means you lose future royalty and licensing income. If the patent turns out to be very profitable, the new owner reaps all the benefits.

Reduced Control Over Commercialisation : Selling the patent gives up your ability to control how the technology is commercialised, which could mean losing out on a potentially lucrative product market if the buyer successfully develops and markets it.

 

Intellectual Property (IP) Theft and Misuse

 

Unauthorised Use or Infringement : Once sold, the new owner could misuse the patent or fail to enforce it properly, allowing competitors to infringe on it without consequences. If they don't protect it well, the patent's value can be compromised.

Resale to a Competitor : The buyer might resell the patent to a competitor, who could then use it to hinder or block your future innovations or enter a related market, creating competition for your other products or technologies.

 

Reduced Market Position and Competitive Advantage

 

Enabling Competition : Selling a core patent to a third party could empower them to compete against you, especially if the patent involves a foundational technology for your business.

Limitations on Future Innovation : If the patent is part of a larger portfolio, selling it could restrict your ability to innovate or pursue new patents in related areas without infringing on the sold patent.

 

Reputational Risks

 

Association with Poor Product Quality : If the patent buyer uses the technology in a sub-par or controversial product, it could damage your reputation, especially if the original invention is closely associated with you or your brand.

Negative Impact on Stakeholders : If the patent sale affects a company's growth or innovation trajectory negatively, it could lead to stakeholder concerns, affecting stock prices, investor confidence, or employee morale.

 

Legal and Financial Risks

 

Potential for Litigation : Patent transactions can lead to legal issues, especially if there are ambiguities in the sale contract. The buyer could sue if they feel misled, or a third party could file an infringement claim.

Complicated Tax Implications : Patent sales involve tax liabilities that vary by jurisdiction. Depending on your location, tax obligations can be significant and may reduce the net profit from the sale.

Valuation Discrepancies : Proper valuation of a patent is challenging and may lead to underselling. If the buyer later capitalises on it greatly, you may feel you received less than the fair value.

 

Regulatory and Compliance Risks

 

Antitrust Issues : In some industries, selling patents to certain players can raise regulatory concerns. For example, if the patent gives the buyer substantial market power, the transaction may be scrutinised by antitrust regulators.

Export Control and Compliance Issues : If the patent involves sensitive technologies, selling it to a foreign entity could involve export controls or compliance with national security regulations, depending on the country.

​

Risk of Patents Becoming Obsolete

 

Technological Advancements : Selling a patent may seem beneficial now, but it risks becoming obsolete if advancements occur in the field. However, if such advancements arise, the buyer could claim the sale price was too high, leading to potential disputes.

​

Loss of Trade Secrets or Know-How

​

Disclosure of Confidential Information : In the process of selling a patent, you may have to disclose sensitive information, which could leak to competitors, affecting your competitive advantage if the deal doesn’t go through.

Loss of Related Know-How : Often, patents are most valuable when accompanied by certain know-how. If the sale includes that expertise, you lose proprietary knowledge that could impact other projects.

 

Mitigating These Risks

 

To minimise these risks, consider:

 

Thorough Due Diligence : Investigate the buyer's intentions, capacity, and reliability to handle the patent responsibly.

Careful Contracting : Draft a well-structured sales agreement with clear terms, representations, and warranties.

Right of First Refusal or Buyback Options : Negotiate options that allow you to repurchase the patent if the buyer doesn't use it as intended.

Market Research and Patent Valuation : Obtain a fair and accurate valuation to avoid undervaluing the patent.

​

Summary

 

By carefully assessing these risks and including protective terms in the sales agreement, you can make a more informed decision and maximise the value while minimising threats associated with selling a patent.